
Rumours of a discovery at Advanced LIGO have resurfaced. (Courtesy: LIGO)
By Hamish Johnston
For the past few days, rumours have been swirling that the Advanced Laser Interferometer Gravitational-wave Observatory (Advanced LIGO) has detected gravitiational waves. Advanced LIGO comprises two huge (kilometre-sized) interferometers in the US, which began taking data in September 2015. The source of the rumours seems to be the physicist and author Lawrence Krauss, who wrote on Twitter yesterday that “My earlier rumour about LIGO has been confirmed by independent sources. Stay tuned! Gravitational waves may have been discovered!! Exciting.”
And it would be very exciting, except for the fact that LIGO spokesperson Gabriela González of Louisiana State University has since told the Guardian newspaper that “The LIGO instruments are still taking data today, and it takes us time to analyse, interpret and review results, so we don’t have any results to share yet.”
So is González exercising the appropriate caution needed when faced with a groundbreaking discovery that must be first confirmed or has Krauss got the wrong end of the stick?
Only time will tell, but in the meantime if you want to know more about Advanced LIGO and the search for gravitational waves, then there is a wealth of information here on physicsworld.com. A good place to start is the 100 Second Science video “What is a gravitational wave?” below in which Ben Stappers of the UK’s University of Manchester explains how gravitational waves are the astrophysical equivalent of throwing a stone into a pond.
Next up is Nergis Mavalvala of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, who played a crucial role in developing the quantum optics used in the upgrade from LIGO to Advanced LIGO. In the 100 Second Science explainer below she describes how the observatory uses interferometry to search for the effect of gravitational waves here on Earth.
Mavalvala also spoke to Physics World’s Louise Mayor in June 2015 about what Advanced LIGO might detect when it started taking data in September. In the video below she suggests that gravitational waves created by the coalescing of two black holes will be the first to be detected by Advanced LIGO – so if Krauss is correct, maybe the Advanced LIGO team is no trying to verify such a measurement?
Now that your appetite has been whetted, there is lots more about gravitational waves – and what they can tell us about the cosmos – here on physicsworld.com. A good place to start is the feature-length article “Sounding out the Big Bang” by the astrophysicist Craig Hogan. This looks at the spectrum of gravitational waves from the extremely low-frequency gravitational waves imprinted on the cosmic microwave background all the way up to the relatively high-frequency signals that may have been seen by Advanced LIGO.
Krauss, and those who seem unable to restrain their wishful thinking, should STOP it.
It is harmful to science and the public’s view of science when the much-hyped hints and rumors fall flat.
We all would like to see a bona fide detection of gravitational waves, but most of us hold our tongues until the evidence becomes compelling.
Let us wait for the LIGO information from its group on the detection or otherwise of the graviational waves, but the Planck satellite data show no sign of the the B-mode polarisation imprinted on the cmb due to the garviational waves from the phenomenon of “inflation”.
What I don’t get is why Lawrence Krauss feels compelled to spread rumors (regardless of whether they are true or not). Can’t he wait patiently like everyone else? Is it compulsion to have his name somehow linked to work he is not part of?
Maybe too many of his students were enrolling in philosophy classes.
If evidence of gravitational waves had been found by LIGO, that would be both exciting and revealing. However, repeated false alarms (like BICEP II, FTL neutrinos, tests of string theory and quantum gravity…) are doing damage to the overall public perception of science. Sadly, it’s impossible to prevent supposedly respectable senior scientists from posting over-enthusiastic and ill-advised tweets which are then picked up and propagated by serious publications. But I do wish they’d stop it.
Trackback: Le quattro forze fondamentali - Francesco Bussola